top of page

Retirement Savings, Organ Donations, and Nobel Prizes: The Rise Of Behavioural Economics

Writer: Tony Jiang
Tony Jiang
Jan 23, 2021
7 min read

If behavioural economics is known for having an impact in resolving one issue in particular, it would be that of retirement savings. The research that behavioural economists did in this domain not only resolved an issue that was plaguing households in Western societies for decades, but it also catapulted the discipline of behavioural economics into the forefront of popular culture and policymaking. As a result of this research, Richard Thaler, one of the fathers of behavioural economics, won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 2017 partly becuse of his contributions to the retirement savings literature.



The Problem

There had been a retirement savings "crisis" in the US for decades up until the mid-2000s, where many Americans had near-zero sums in their retirement savings plans. Even if people did have some money saved up, it was definitely not enough for a happy retirement. This problem was not only an American issue, but it was an issue that tormented people in many Western economies.


Retirement plans in the US primarily consist of 401(k) "defined-contribution" plans, which typically require individuals to independently decide how much to save for retirement and manage their savings throughout their professional careers. Although there are substantial benefits to joining a 401(k) plan, such as tax-deductible contributions and employer matching (which is essentially free money!), many people at the time were not saving for retirement at all, and those that were saving were probably not saving enough. Those versed in economics will quickly notice that this is an issue of present bias: people valued present consumption more than future consumption, and neglected to save for the future in order to satisfy their immediate desires.


So how did behavioural economics tackle this issue? Part of the solution, surprisingly, came from research in organ donations.



Defaults and Organ Donation

In the past, people had to register to become organ donors. It was a completely voluntary process, and if you didn't register, it was assumed you didn't want to be an organ donor. However, there was a disparity here, as 85% of Americans approved of organ donation but only 28% were registered organ donors. Consequently, between 1995 and 2003, over 45,000 Americans died waiting for an organ transplant. Clearly, not enough people were willing to sign up to be an organ donor, even though many were accepting of the practice.


During this time, the research on default options was growing, and many European countries had implemented a policy of presumed consent to tackle this issue of insufficient organ donation. This meant that rather than having to register to be an organ donor, the default was changed so that people were automatically registered to be organ donors unless they chose to opt-out of the program.


Although ethical issues were raised with this policy (as people could be donors without knowing), changing the default had a massive effect on enrollment rates and saved many lives, as shown by the graphic below. Enrollment rates were around 99% for countries with the automatic enrollment default, while they were substantially lower for countries with non-automatic enrollment (shown in blue and gold respectively). The default option was shown to matter significantly on people's decisions to become organ donors. This research had a large influence on organ donation policies today, where many countries have now adopted this opt-out default.

Depicted from: Johnson & Goldstein (2003)



Defaults and Retirement Savings

Changing the default was not only proposed as a solution for solving insufficient organ donations, but also for the retirement savings crisis. Madrian & Shea (2001) conducted a well-known study which examined what happens if the default was changed so that employees were automatically enrolled into a retirement savings plan rather than having to register into one. They compared the two default options in a study and found that with the opt-out default, more than 90% of employees were enrolled within 3 months of employment and 98% after 36 months. This was significantly greater than the opt-in approach, where only 20% of employees were enrolled in 401(k) plans within 3 months of employment and 65% after 36 months. Simply changing the default had huge effects on enrollment in a retirement savings plans!


You might be thinking, how did something as simple as changing the default option have such drastic effects on behaviour? There are several potential explanations. One is that defaults exploit the fact that people have a status-quo bias and are prone to inertia. That is, people typically prefer the current state that they are in, and often prefer not to act if the process of changing their present state is effortful. When the default was no automatic enrollment, people may not have bothered with getting in to the 401(k) plan unless they really wanted to. Now that the default was changed to automatic enrollment, people may not bother with getting out of the 401(k) plan unless they really wanted to.


Another explanation could be the recommendation effect: people may have thought that the default plan was the plan that employers recommended, or the plan that most people were on. As we are social creatures, we tend to use the actions of others as cues for our own behaviour, and this can explain why we follow the default, since we believe it to be the advantageous choice recommended to us.



Save More Tomorrow

Although changing the default proved to be highly successful with increasing the enrollment rate, it was only part of the solution to the retirement savings crisis. Choi et al. (2004) found that despite the fact that changing defaults led to a large increase in enrollment rates, many people were still saving insufficient amounts. Specifically, most people were saving at a constant 2% per year, which was not enough for retirement. This 2% per year was the default savings rate of these automatic enrollment plans, and people neglected to adjust their savings rate after they were automatically enrolled -- proof that defaults can also have negative effects if not designed properly.


This is where Richard Thaler comes into play. He and co-author Shlomo Bernatzi proposed the "Save More Tomorrow" program (SMT), which combined automatic enrollment with a series of automatic escalations in savings rates over time which coincided with pay rises. In other words, participants were automatically enrolled in the program, pre-committed to save higher amounts into their 401(k) over time, and also pre-committed to save higher amounts whenever they experienced an increase in salary.


There are several psychological factors as to why this program was hypothesized to work. Firstly, self-control restrictions are easier to adopt in the future rather than today. It's easier to say you'll start or stop doing something tomorrow rather than today. A classic example of this is dieting: you always tell yourself you'll start your diet soon, just not today. This is a key component of the SMT program, as you might be happier and less likely to opt-out of the program knowing that the savings increases are adopted in the future rather than the present.


Secondly, it avoids loss-aversion. People are incredibly sensitive to losses, and the SMT program helps people not view savings as a loss by synchronizing pay raises with savings increases. As a result, people will never see their paychecks go down and never think they are losing money by participating in the program, and therefore be less tempted to opt-out of the program.


Finally, it again plays on people's inertia. Because of the automatic nature of the program, people don't have to do anything and still be saving sufficient amounts for retirement. This is what is so beautiful about the idea: it makes it effortless and stress-free to be saving enough for retirement. People don't need to have any financial knowledge or compute any complex calculations about how much to save -- it's all done automatically!


The research showed considerable success of the program, where those enrolled in the plan quadrupled their savings rates from 3.5% to 13.6% in less than 4 years, while very few participants opted out. The success of the program caught on to businesses and policymakers, and today more and more employers are offering automatic enrollment and automatic escalation retirement plans as a result. As of 2020, over 60% of employers offering 401(k) retirement plans are automatically enrolling their employees, while three quarters of these plans are also automatically escalating employee's savings rates over time.



Legacy

The success of behavioural economics with retirement savings amplified the field into popular knowledge and changed future retirement savings policies substantially. Behavioural economics was shown to be not only a theoretical deviation from standard economics, but now had clear real-world applications which produced incredibly effective results. Richard Thaler's research in retirement savings played a large role in him attaining the Nobel Prize, and also led to his bestselling book "Nudge" -- which has inspired the creation of hundreds "nudge units" around the world, the most notable of which being the Behavioural Insights Team, who play a prominent role in advising governments on how to design and apply policies. I talk a bit about how nudges have been employed in combatting the Covid-19 pandemic in an article post found here.


All in all, the work done retirement savings work inspired a whole succession of development of the field of behavioural economics, and has led to the popularization of behavioural economics in the modern world.




To end the post on an unrelated note, here is a brief cameo of Richard Thaler with Selena Gomez in the movie "The Big Short", where they explain synthetic CDOs, the hot-hand fallacy, and how they contributed to the financial crisis of 2008:



Sources


Nudge Book:

Thaler, R. H., & Sunstein, C. R. (2008). Nudge: improving decisions about health, wealth, and happiness. New Haven: Yale University Press


Defaults and Organ Donations:

Johnson, E. J., & Goldstein, D. G. (2003). Do Defaults Save Lives?. Science, 302, 1338-1339.


Defaults and Retirement Savings:

Madrian, B. C., & Shea, D. F. (2001). The power of suggestion: Inertia in 401 (k) participation and savings behavior. The Quarterly journal of economics, 116(4), 1149-1187.


Choi, J. J., Laibson, D., Madrian, B. C., & Metrick, A. (2004). For better or for worse: Default effects and 401 (k) savings behavior. In Perspectives on the Economics of Aging (pp. 81-126). University of Chicago Press.


Save More Tomorrow:

Thaler, R. H., & Benartzi, S. (2004). Save more tomorrow™: Using behavioral economics to increase employee saving. Journal of political Economy, 112(S1), S164-S187.


Benartzi, S., & Thaler, R. H. (2013). Behavioral economics and the retirement savings crisis. Science, 339(6124), 1152-1153.


An overview of automatic enrollment and escalation plans in 2020:


Behavioural Insights Team:

https://www.bi.team/

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

©2021 by Tony Jiang. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page