Nudges And The Behavioural Science Behind The Covid-19 Crisis
Updated: Jan 29, 2021

Given the severity of the recent crisis, I thought it would be only fitting to make my first blog post about behavioural science and Covid-19. The global pandemic has obviously had a huge disruptive effect worldwide, but some countries such as Taiwan and New Zealand have done a fantastic job in containing it, while other countries such as the UK (where I am currently writing from) are seeing cases skyrocket and hospitals under pressure. In this blog post, I will discuss some topics in behavioural science that relate to Covid-19.
Individual vs collective interests
Not only does Covid-19 present a massive challenge for the scientific community, but it is also a challenge for behavioural scientists and policy. The spread of the virus depends heavily on people's abidence with the rules, and although a majority of people do comply, some are undermining the restrictions and putting the collective interest at stake. People are often appalled when reading articles of others attending illegal parties or seeing people without a mask on indoors, since it demonstrates the willingness of others to cancel out the efforts of those contributing to the collective effort.
In the scope of behavioural economics, there are two potential explanations that I can think of for this sort of individualistic behaviour. Behavioural economics is born out of the idea that people make decisions which are not generally considered "rational" from a neoclassical economics perspective, and behavioural economists have designed models to attempt capture these deviations from rationality. One explanation is that people may feel that the individual payoffs from going outside outweigh the payoffs from staying at home to contribute to the collective goal. These people may gain more utility from going outside than staying at home, even if their decision risks the continual spread of the virus. Another explanation is that people may be myopic in their decision-making and neglect the long term collective benefits for the instant gratification of going out. This is analogous to behaviours such as quitting smoking: the long term health benefits from quitting smoking are immense, but when the temptation comes, people often fail to quit for the instant gratification of another cigarette. People may lose sight of the long term societal goal of eradicating the virus for the short term benefit of a day out with friends.
Media, risk, and emotions
The media also plays a huge role in the way we percieve the threat of the virus. Typically we hear reports of how the virus has impacted us negatively (eg. we hear reports of how many people are infected or die rather than how most people recover or only experience mild symptoms), and this negative framing may affect people's emotions and perception of the threat of the virus. People can misjudge probabilities and make poorer decisions when emotions play a role in decision making, which can explain, for example, the initial waves of panic at the start of the pandemic.
On the other hand, now that we have become more accustomed to life with the virus and have more information about it, people may be also underestimating the likelihood they contract the virus. This may lead to a sense of optimism bias, where people may feel that they are unlikely to contract the virus, and even if they do contract it, they have the knowledge that they are unlikely to die from it. Obviously, this perception is incredibly risky, especially given that the unobservable nature of the virus can makes people misjudge the risk of contracting and spreading the virus. Since people often only see symptoms after several days or not see any symptoms at all, people may mistakenly think they are healthy and infect people without even realizing it.
Nudges and Public Policy
The UK government, as well as some other countries around the world and organizations such as the WHO, have adopted behavioural nudges into their policy toolkits to try to combat the spread of coronavirus. Nudges are a set of policy tools which rely on psychological insights to draw people into making certain decisions without restricting individual freedom of choice. For this reason, they are considered to be a policy of "paternal libertarianism": a paternalistic government wanting to guide and trust citizens to make good societal decisions without the need to create strict laws or bans. They are powerful for their cost-effectiveness, and their success in domains such as increasing organ donations and improving retirement saving has brought behavioural science to the forefront of public policy.
Here is an example of a behavioural nudge by the National Health Service in the UK (and I'm sure you have seen many similar nudges wherever you live). There are several components in this poster that are cleverly designed based off insights from behavioural science:

Photo: Dinendra Haria/LNP/Shutterstock
First, the message appeals to people's inherent desire to be socially moral. Decades worth of studies in behavioural science show that people have clear prosocial tendencies, such as reciprocity, altruism, and fairness. The message "Stay Home To Help Us Save Lives" attempts to appeal to this aspect of human nature by asking us to reciprocate the kindness of the hard work made by NHS workers by staying at home.
Second, it uses negative framing to induce an emotional reaction. The words "If you go out, you can spread it. People will die." are delibrately designed to create an emotional response so that people feel more afraid to go out. Rather than saying something more neutral like "Going out increases the probability of spreading the disease", they make it clear that their actions will definitely lead to more deaths. This message also exploit's our common feeling of guilt aversion: We have a strong aversion to feeling guilty, so this message makes us feel as if other people's deaths will be on our hands if we go out.
Finally, the main message is incredibly salient and easy to understand. The main message is in large bold letters which contrast with the dark image in the background, while the language used is very straightforward. A critical component of designing behavioural nudges is that the main message should be salient for them to have impact.
Paternal libertarianism seemingly ineffective
However, as we approach a third lockdown in the UK, behavioural nudges have shown to not be effective enough in producing a drastic enough change in behaviour to combat the virus. Indeed, behavioural insights typically come from lab experiments, and given the multifaceted and unique circumstances of this crisis, these may not be sufficient enough to induce large-scale behaviour change. This has led to behavioural science to understandably come under a lot of scrutiny in recent months. Countries which have more successfully combatted the virus were quick to implement laws, bans, and travel restrictions -- policies far different from the paternalistic libertarian approach adopted by the UK and US.
Behavioural science has had many successes in other policy domains, but when it comes to the coronavirus pandemic, it has proven relatively ineffective thus far. Perhaps stricter laws combined with behavioural nudges are the way forward for countries that are particularly struggling to contain the virus.
Read More:
On Behavioural Science and Covid-19:
Bavel, J.J.V., Baicker, K., Boggio, P.S. et al. Using social and behavioural science to support COVID-19 pandemic response. Nat Hum Behav 4, 460–471 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-0884-z
On designing and implementing nudges:
Dolan, P., Hallsworth, M., Halpern, D., King, D., & Vlaev, I. (2010). MINDSPACE: influencing behaviour for public policy.



Very interesting and informative article!