Is Reciprocity Instinctive? An Experimental Study Investigating Our Innate Human Nature
Updated: Jan 13, 2021
Reciprocity is something which has a huge influence on our decision making whether we know it or not. For instance, smiling waitresses recieve higher tips than unfriendly ones, giving out free samples increases product sales, and charities which give out small gifts are more likely to recieve donations. These are all examples of how a small act of kindness by a salesperson can influence a consumer's purchasing decisions. Specifically, these are all instances of positive reciprocity (when a kind gesture is met with a kind response) as opposed to negative reciprocity (when a cruel gesture is met with a cruel response; for example, theft rates go up when employee wages are cut).
Our tendency to reciprocate is a social behaviour which developed as our species evolved to increase our chances of survival. However, an interesting question which has puzzled philosophers, psychologists, and economists alike is a question of our inherent human nature: is it that we have an innate desire to reciprocate the kindness of others? Or are we actually more inherently selfish, and we reciprocate the kindness of others only because it is socially acceptable?
I am particularly interested in this subject of human nature and social norms, and wrote my master's dissertation on this question of instinctive reciprocity. My research was on a relatively unexplored subject, as many studies had investigated topics such as instinctive desires for trust, altruism, and fairness, but few had examined instinctive reciprocity. To investigate this, I programmed and conducted an online experiment which used insights from game theory and psychology to examine whether people made the decision to reciprocate instinctively, or whether people had to effortfully think about making reciprocity decisions. In this blog post, I will summarize the design and the main findings. If you are interested, you can find the full paper here!
Trust Game and Dual-Processes Theory
The experiment consisted of participants playing a modified version of the trust game (also known as the investment game), first introduced by an influential paper by Joyce Berg and colleagues in 1995. The trust game depicts a hypothetical scenario between two individuals, for instance, an investor and a manager. The game follows the following steps:
Both players start with a sum of money. The investor goes first, and is asked to choose an amount of money to invest in the manager (ie. how much do they trust the manager).
This amount of money is then tripled (depicting a return on investment), and is given to the manager.
The manager then is required to decide how to split the tripled sum of money (plus their initial sum of money) between themselves and the investor.
We can see how reciprocity plays an important psychological role in this game. By deciding to invest, the investor is placing a great deal of trust in the manager to return them with a profit, but the manager could always betray the investor and selfishly keep the entire tripled sum for themselves. Indeed, this is what neoclassical economists (who believe that people are selfish and rational) would predict would happen in this game. However, many iterations of this game have shown that this selfish prediction would not happen, and that it is through the notion reciprocity that the manager would want the investor to make a profit. Because the investor took a large risk by trusting the manager, the manager would wish to reward to the trusting investor for their kindness. Negative reciprocity is also possible, where a manager may be inclined to return nothing to an untrusting investor.
To investigate whether reciprocity was instinctive or effortful, I utilized insights from the dual-processes theory of decision making. This dual-processes theory postulates that there are two conflicting "systems" which guide our decision making: The emotional and automatic "System 1" and the calculated and thoughtful "System 2". Our decisions are often guided by these two systems, and the quality of our decisions often depends on which system is used. System 1 is extremely adept at making quick judgements (eg. deciding to run when a lion is chasing you) while System 2 is good for cognitively demanding decisions (eg. solving a complex math question). Imagine using System 2 if a lion was chasing you, or using System 1 when doing the math question -- you'd be eaten up while you're still thinking about how to react, and you'd get the answer completely wrong!
In the experiment, participants were paired and randomly assigned to be either the investor or the manager. Half of the managers played the trust game under a "time pressure" condition, where managers only had ten seconds to make a decision of how much money to return, while the other half played the game under a "time delay" condition, where managers had an unlimited amount of time to make a decision and were encouraged to think about their decision. In the time pressure condition, managers are forced to use their emotional System 1 processes, while those in the time delay condition could deliberate on their reciprocity decisions.
Results
I was able to replicate the results of many trust game experiments, where a majority of managers positively reciprocated the investors trust by returning an amount which was either profitable or equalled the investment, while investors who were untrusting were met with negative reciprocation from managers. However, overall average returns in the time pressure condition were only slightly greater than that of the time condition, and this difference was statistically insignificant. This means I could not conclusively say that reciprocity is more of an instinctive response than an effortful one. There may be a few reasons for this insignificant result.
One reason may be that 10 seconds may not have been impactful enough to force out an urgent System 1 response. Other studies use techniques such as a secondary memorization task (where participants are required to memorize a set of seven letters while they make a decision) to force people into using System 1, as their System 2 would be occupied. In my study, ten seconds may still have been enough time to allow for System 2 thought. Another reason may have been that reciprocity is a phenomenon that uses both System 1 and System 2 processes. Perhaps we are both instinctively inclined to reciprocate the kindness of others and also have a conscious preference for reciprocation.
Implications
Evidently, further research is required to answer this question. The implications of this subject are far reaching, as they can reveal a lot about our inherent human nature.
One area which this research would have significant impact in is public policy. Many governments around the world use behavioural nudges to influence citizen's decision making, and knowing how quickly people make reciprocity judgements can help decision scientists in their thinking of how to design nudges. For example, to combat the Covid-19 crisis, the National Health Service in the UK has created slogans such as "Stay Home To Help Us Save Lives" (I wrote an article about Covid-19 and nudges, which you can find here!). This message exploits the notion that humans wish to reciprocate the kindness of others, as it is reminding people that the NHS is doing their part to combat the virus so you should reciprocate by doing your part. Knowing how quickly people make these reciprocity decisions can help policymakers understand the efficacy of these nudges and how to better design nudges around the notion of reciprocity.
Another policy area which this research could have impact is in understanding corruption behaviour. I wrote an article for The Decision Lab (found here) which explains how the typical corruption scenario is similar to the trust game, where decisions depend on the psychological notions of trust and reciprocity. Understanding how quickly people are attracted to bribes can also help with designing anticorruption policies.
Finally, this research can have impact in understanding consumer behaviour and help companies with their approach to making sales. For instance, companies may train their customer service representatives and staff to be more friendly to customers and clients in order to elicit instinctive reciprocal responses. Or companies could adopt sales techniques such as the aforementioned free sample strategy. Understanding how people make decisions based on social norms such as reciprcoity could have large benefits for companies and organizations.
Further Reading
Jiang, H. (2020). Is reciprocity instinctive or effortful? The effect of time pressure in an experimental trust game.
A good overview of economics and reciprocity:
Fehr, E. and Gächter, S. (2000). Fairness and retaliation: The economics of reciprocity. Journal of economic perspectives, 14(3):159-181.
Smiling waitresses study:
Tidd, K.L and J.S. Lochard. (1978). Monetary Significance of the Affiliative Smile: A Case for Reciprocal Altruism. Bull. Psychonom. Soc. 11, pp. 344-46.
Free samples and product sales:
Cialdini, Robert. (1993). Influence–The Psychology of Persuasion. New York: Quill William Morrow.
Charitable giving:
Falk, A. (2007). Gift exchange in the field. Econometrica, 75(5):1501-1511.
Trust Game:
Berg, J., Dickhaut, J., and McCabe, K. (1995). Trust, reciprocity, and social history. Games and economic behavior, 10(1):122-142.
Dual-Processes Theory (and a fantastic book outlining the major findings that gave birth to the field of behavioural economics):
Kahneman, D. (2011). Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Neural evidence for Dual-Processes Theory:
McClure, S. M., Laibson, D. I., Loewenstein, G., and Cohen, J. D. (2004). Separate neural systems value immediate and delayed monetary rewards. Science, 306(5695):503-507.



Comments